When you purchase through links on our internet site , we may earn an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it works .
As the alleged gunslinger in last calendar week ’s Aurora , Colo. , movie theatre of operations killings made his first appearance in court today ( July 23 ) , his every facial tic was scrutinized for clues as to why he might have launched his flack against theater - goers at a midnight screening of the newest Batman movie last week .
But even if James Holmes eventually unveil his motives , psychologists say , the answer are unlikely to be acceptable .
Bullet holes in glass.
" Even when you draw out the pieces together , theyreally do n’t append up , " state Mary Muscari , a forensic nurse at Binghamton University in New York who has research mass killers . The histories of mass gunslinger sometimes show common threads , such as a serial publication of disappointments leading up to the event , Muscari said . But in the oddment , the spark that drives people to violence is obscure , and the effect are rarefied enough that it ’s voiceless to generalize from case to case .
" There are certainly a lot of people who have a flock of things go wrong , and they ’re not committing aggregated murder , " Muscari told LiveScience . " Even when you front at mental sickness , most peoplewith mental illness are not violent . "
look for for a common thread
Holmes allegedly recruit a theater showing the Batman moving-picture show " The Dark Knight Rises " before long after the movie begin on July 20 . Dressed in protective gearing and bearing tear gas and three guns , Holmes opened fire on the crowd , killing 12 . [ 10 Most Destructive Human Behaviors ]
Mass killers follow different enough shape that it ’s incredibly difficult for researchers to pin down common thread , said Frank Farley , a psychologist at Temple University and the preceding president of the American Psychological Association .
" Each one is a recipe with some vulgar ingredients , perhaps , but then constituent that differ , " Farley told LiveScience . " For deterrent example , many are snowy male between 20 and 30 . On the other hand , there are millions of such males in this country . "
And there are exclusion to every drift . Seung - Hui Cho , who killed 32 during ashooting violent disorder at Virginia Techin 2007 , was of Korean descent . Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold , the perpetrators of the Columbine High School massacre in Littleton , Colo. , were 18 and 17 years old , severally . In a relatively uncommon case of a distaff perpetrator , University of Alabama , Huntsville prof Amy Bishop has been charged with obliterate three and injure three more during a workplace shot in 2010 .
Mass killer can point strangers , coworkers or family members , Muscari said . A rough-cut motivation is revenge , she added .
" retaliation is a fluid thing , " Muscari said . " It could be something very specific against a certain person , it could be a worldwide affair in the workplace or school , or it could be very diffuse , where they go shoot up a restaurant . "
Mass cause of death are often depict associally isolate loner , but that ’s not quite accurate , said Katherine Newman , a sociologist at Johns Hopkins University who has studied high - school and university shootings .
" In fact , they are very seldom lone wolf , " Newman articulate . " After the fact , when you question multitude who have it away them , they ’ll say , ' He had friends . I was one of his Quaker . ' But in oecumenical , their societal experience is not one of easy incorporation . "
In other word , many aggregative shooters , rather than want to be alone , have a history of struggling to connect . They experience rejection by their compeer or they draw back from potential friendships , assuming they ’ll be rejected if they render . They believe they ’re perceive as peanut , Newman tell LiveScience .
" They require to be seen as notorious , and unfortunately , there ’s a lot of societal reinforcement for the glamour of being notorious , " she said . " They think how cool it will be when everybody get it on their name … I know this sounds absurd , but in some way of life , repulsion or notoriety is preferable from their gunpoint of view from anon. and insignificant . " [ 10 Surprising Facts About the Teen Brain ]
Extreme events
But even here , the psychology of mass killer whale persist evasive . pot of mass struggle with friendships , Newman enjoin , and only a " tiny , flyspeck infinitesimal fraction of them [ does ] something like this . "
As soberingly frequent as volume shooting may seem , they ’re extremely rare from a scientific view , researchers said . There has been a gradual increase in multiple - victim homicides , though the statistics are still low : 3.1 per centum of murders in 1976 and 4.4 pct in 2005 , according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics . That statistic includes all homicides with multiple victim , not only sprees like that in Aurora .
The larger the group of citizenry psychologist can study , the more they can turn over into suit of behaviour , and the more certain they can be of their results . Mass killers just are n’t very common .
compound the problem , Farley read , is that most psychological exam and theory are based on more or less normal psychology . It ’s a paradigm that can excuse things like happiness , depression and anxiousness , but it does n’t work as well when faced with extreme cases , he said . [ Top 10 Controversial Psychiatric Disorders ]
" I worry that we may not even be able to get a good fix , in a sense , on his mental health status , " Farley said of Holmes . " There just are n’t enough quotation peak . "
Though little information has been released on Holmes ' mental health , Farley aver he ’d be surprised to regain out that the say shot waspsychotic , give the months of provision that went into his fling .
Calling for prevention
Farley and others contacted by LiveScience could only conjecture on Holmes ' motives , given the scant information available about the showcase . There have been shootings in the past by struggling graduate scholarly person , Farley said , citing a 1991 murder - felo-de-se at the University of Iowa in which a supporter of Farley ’s along with four other professors were killed . The atmospheric pressure of subsist up to expectations in graduate school can be very trying , Newman said , potentially exacerbating trigger-happy tendencies .
There are other question to ask as well , Farley said , from how socially isolated Holmes was to why he may have developed a focus on the Batman dealership , die his hair a Joker - alike shade of red ( Batman merchandise was also found in Holmes ' apartment ) .
Psychologists interview for this tale agreed that the contract problem is to find a elbow room to prevent thesekilling spreesbefore they happen . Even in people who will never snap , the problems of social isolation and feelings of insignificance are wicked burdens , Newman said .
" It ’s not so much to catch shooters , because we do it that ’s very difficult , but actually to plow very widespread problem that reach jillion of kids , " she said .
Though the U.S. homicide rate has dropped in the last decennium or so in the U.S. , psychological science should also focus more on less headline - grabbingviolence , Farley said , argue for a concert movement to hit the books what he called the " heart of darkness " in humans .
" I sit here in Philadelphia with 400 homicides a year , " Farley said . " It ’s not just mass slaying . It ’s just everyday slaughter . "
